End-of-Year Housing Decline: was TRID to Blame?

a house floating in the water with a red roof

In December 2015, the National Association of Realtors (NAR) reported a precipitous 10.5% drop in sales of existing homes. Many were quick to point fingers at the recently-implemented TRID (TILA-RESPA Integrated Disclosure) rule and its new closing demands as the culprit, but a recent article in Forbes questions how warranted the criticism really is.

TRID became effective October 3, 2015. The goal of TRID is to make the mortgage process more transparent for homebuyers, and this has created new timelines, forms, and best practices for lenders and realtors.

TRID’s Effect on the 2015 End-of-Year Sales Market

So why are real estate professionals blaming TRID as the cause of the sales slowdown? For one, it slowed down the timeframe for closings considerably by adding three days to both the front and back of the mortgage process. In November 2014, the average mortgage loan took an average of 36 days to close; one year later, after TRID’s implementation, that number is now close to 41 days.

Other Contributing Factors

The delivery requirements for the Loan Estimate and the Closing Disclosure Form are significant, but there are other elements at play. Signed purchase contracts, a critical indicator measuring pending home sales, were in decline for several months before November. Additionally, inventory and affordability challenges continued to hold back sales for a large buyer pool. Finally, professionals in their mid-30s— a demographic commonly associated with home purchase — are choosing to stick with rental options more than in years past.

Misplaced TRID Backlash

Mark Greene of Forbes states that the media and mortgage leaders’ position that TRID is to blame for the November slowdown is hasty and inaccurate. TRID did not cause the delays in closing, he says; rather, lenders and mortgage professionals who were unprepared to adapt to the changes did. Instead of blaming the policy itself, Greene says that these entities should pay special care to reviewing borrower information, delivering forms in a timely fashion, and ensuring complete TRID compliance. Many lenders may find this position difficult to accept, but with little assistance coming from Congress or the CFPB, there’s value in acknowledging the reality of the situation. That’s the only way lenders will be able to create real, sustainable strategies for TRID compliance going forward.

Working with Lakeside Title Company

Lakeside Title Company serves lenders and realtors from 14 convenient locations across Maryland, Pennsylvania, and Virginia. Every year, we close over 4,000 transactions throughout the D.C. metro area, Maryland, Northern Virginia, and Southern Pennsylvania. For an array of title insurance and closing services for refinancing, residential sales, resales, new construction, and 1031 exchanges, please visit our homepage or contact Lakeside Title Company today. If you found the information in this blog useful, we invite you to share this information on your company’s social media pages or with your friends and colleagues.

Need Legal Advice?

If you have a question for an attorney, or have a colleague, coworker, client, friend, or family member who could benefit from Lakeside Title Company’s blog click here to contact Lakeside Title Company OR Deardorff, Rath & Pichon, LLC.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *